Reported by us | Chesterton

The fire, the depot and the brick blocks that built downtown Chesterton

A PC360 Special looks back at the April 1902 fire that nearly leveled Chesterton's downtown, the brick blocks its merchants raised within two years and the 1914 depot the town welcomed with a banquet.

By Aaron J. Souza and the PC360 Community Desk | Published Nov. 19, 2026 | Last verified Nov. 19, 2026, 7:01 a.m. CT

CHESTERTON, Ind. In the spring of 1907, The Chesterton Tribune told its readers that more than 50 people had stood at the Lake Shore railroad station one Sunday, waiting for the westbound evening train in a raw wind, because the "little ten by twelve room" the railroad used for a waiting room could not hold them all.

The paper did the arithmetic for the railroad, too, since the station had taken in $12,200 in passenger fares in 1906, more than $1,000 a month. Then it ended with a line that still carries some heat: the town board, it said, would be justified in reminding the company "that there is such a town as Chesterton on the map, and that it needs a new depot."

Chesterton got its depot in the end, after the old one burned in 1913, and by then a downtown of brick already stood across the street, raised by merchants from the ashes of an earlier fire in 1902. This look back is drawn from the National Register of Historic Places records local historians prepared for the depot and the downtown in the late 1990s, the Westchester Public Library's Duneland History Center and the old Chesterton postcards of the Steven R. Shook collection.

From Coffee Creek to Chesterton

Settlers founded a village called Coffee Creek in 1833, the same year William Thomas opened the Thomas Inn for travelers on the road between Michigan City and Valparaiso, according to the National Register nomination for the downtown. Over the years the place answered to Thomas Mill, Coffee Creek and Calumet.

The railroad laid its tracks nearby in 1852, and landowners began moving the village toward the rails. That year the Thomas brothers, who ran the local mill, sold the railroad a parcel for a depot and a wood yard for $120, the depot's nomination says, and in 1869 the village took the name Chesterton. Until 1872 it was the only stop between Chicago and Michigan City.

With the rails came business: in the 1880s, eight brickyards in nearby Porter were supplying Chicago's growing building market, and by 1882 the area's yards were turning out 50 million bricks a year. Downtown Chesterton filled with general stores and 17 saloons. After a national panic in 1893 took down several of the town's key industries, new ones came, among them the Warren Featherbone Company, which made corsets and collar stays out of turkey feathers.

The fire of 1902

By 1900, downtown was a crowd of wooden storefronts along Calumet Road, which the old postcards call Valparaiso Street, and along Broadway, once known as Main Street. On April 6, 1902, fire raged along Calumet Road and nearly leveled the downtown, the district's nomination says.

Eleven buildings and everything in them were lost, the nomination counts, and with them went nearly every kind of business the town had: a feed store, a bakery, a theater, a hotel, a meat market, a hardware and paint store, a general store, three saloons, the town hall, the newspaper office, a pool hall, a grocery, a harness shop and a livery. In 1984, the Tribune called it "the worst disaster in the history of the town."

Within two years, merchants had rebuilt most of downtown in brick, likely from the yards in Porter and Chesterton, and the brickwork is so alike from one storefront to the next that the nomination suggests a small group of craftsmen built most of them. The Tribune wrote that the new buildings "brought modernity and beauty to our business district."

The town put up a new hall right on Calumet, with a bay for the fire department on the ground floor and town offices and a meeting hall upstairs, and set a stone tablet over its windows reading "CITY HALL" above the year 1902. The Tribune commissioned its own two-story brick home at 193 N. Calumet in 1904, its name on a stone tablet over the windows.

A walk down Calumet

The nomination's building-by-building inventory names who kept shop where, and for how long. The Knights of Pythias met upstairs in the Smith Block from 1903 until 1968. Joseph Heward opened a drugstore in 1907 in the block H.F. Carlson had built, and it stayed in business until the 1970s. On the flatiron corner of Broadway and Calumet, Harry Smith kept the family dry goods store, M. Smith and Son, until his death in 1961, and his son Richard ran it until 1973.

At 125 N. Calumet, where a saloon had stood since the 1880s, Jeffrey's Motion Pictures showed silent films from 1910 to 1915, a pool hall came next, and Flannery's Tavern opened in the mid-1930s. Postcards from those years show horses and buggies parked beside Railroad Park, the green by the tracks known today as Thomas Centennial Park.

The depot the town waited for

The old frame depot the Tribune had complained about burned on Nov. 22, 1913. Just over a year later, in December 1914, the New York Central, which had long owned the Lake Shore line, finished a new passenger depot and a separate freight depot. Chesterton threw a banquet for 135 prominent people and railroad executives, with an elaborate menu and musicians brought out from Chicago, and the depot's nomination says it was the first celebration of its kind the New York Central had held.

The depot was built long and low, brick below and stucco above, under a red terra cotta tile roof whose deep eaves rest on big Prairie Style brackets. A canopy on heavy wooden posts ran about 40 feet off the east end, where passengers waited for their trains. Inside, the east half held the waiting room, the ticket booth and the operator's bay, and the west half the baggage room and offices. In the steam years, the nomination says, farmers were paid for cordwood brought to the depot lot to burn in the locomotives, and part of the lot served as a cattle yard.

After the war

Freight kept moving, but passenger traffic thinned after World War II. In 1966, the New York Central ended passenger service at Chesterton and sold the depot to the town for $35,000. It became a police station and offices for the town water company, and later housed a string of private tenants, until an engineering firm, Duneland Group, leased it in October 1995 and set about restoring it, taking down suspended ceilings to bring back the original height and wooden beams of the old waiting room.

Jim Morrow of the Heritage Society of Northwest Indiana wrote up the depot for the National Register, and he and Beverly Overmyer wrote up the downtown. The depot was listed in 1998 and the Chesterton Commercial Historic District in 1999, its nomination calling the Calumet Road blocks the best example of a small railroad town commercial center in Porter County. The old depot at 220 Broadway is home today to the Duneland Chamber of Commerce.

Where the memories are kept

Much of what Chesterton remembers is kept in another landmark, the George Brown Mansion, a Queen Anne house built in 1885 at 700 W. Porter Ave., with masonry by contractor Christopher Lembke, the downtown nomination says. The Westchester Public Library started its history museum in 1998 and moved it into the mansion in 2005 under a lease with the Duneland School Corp., and today it is the library's Duneland History Center.

Its collections include the Chesterton Tribune Photo Archives of Duneland images the paper published, along with maps, phone books and newspapers. The center is open to the public on Wednesdays and the second and fourth Saturdays from noon to 5 p.m., and by appointment on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Fridays at 219-983-9715.

The depot has outlasted the passenger trains that once stopped there, and it shares the National Register with the brick blocks raised from the ashes of 1902. In 1907, the Tribune wanted the railroad reminded that there was such a town as Chesterton on the map, and more than a century later, the map still says so.

See also

Label: Reported by us.

Corrections

No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.

Sources (9)

  1. New York Central Railroad Passenger Depot, National Register of Historic Places registration form, Jim Morrow, Heritage Society of Northwest Indiana, 1997, National Park Service NPGallery, NRIS 98001103
  2. Chesterton Commercial Historic District, National Register of Historic Places registration form, Jim Morrow and Beverly Overmyer, Heritage Society of Northwest Indiana, 1998, National Park Service NPGallery, NRIS 99001102
  3. George Brown Mansion, National Register of Historic Places record, National Park Service NPGallery, NRIS 98001101
  4. Duneland History Center, Westchester Public Library
  5. A Brief History, Westchester Public Library
  6. "A New Depot Needed Here," The Chesterton Tribune, April 4, 1907, as transcribed with the circa 1925 depot postcard in the Steven R. Shook collection, Wikimedia Commons
  7. Town Hall on Valparaiso Street, circa 1910, postcard, Steven R. Shook collection, Wikimedia Commons
  8. Duneland Chamber of Commerce, contact information
  9. Photo: Lake Shore Railroad Depot, 1916, postcard postmarked Aug. 29, 1916, Steven R. Shook collection, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

This story on the full site