Easton Park fines return to Chesterton's storm water board Monday after staff counted $16,250 more in violations
The board fined the subdivision's developer $7,250 in September and left a stop work order in place, and a homeowners coalition says a Jan. 31 turnover could leave residents with responsibility for the storm water system.
Chesterton's Storm Water Management Board takes up the Easton Park fines again Monday, Nov. 16, a month after town engineering staff counted $16,250 in new violations at the subdivision on top of the $7,250 the board imposed on its developer in September.
The board meets at 5:30 p.m. at Town Hall, 726 Broadway, with "Easton Park Fines" listed under old business. The meeting is open to the public, includes a public comment period and streams live on the town's YouTube channel, youtube.com/@TownofChesterton. Board members are President Thomas Kopko, Paul Stofko and Victoria Wittig.
What the board found
The fines came out of an administrative hearing at the board's Aug. 17 meeting, where town staff presented evidence against Olson Farm LLC, which holds the storm water permits for Easton Park, and the developer cross-examined the town's witnesses and presented its own evidence.
On Sept. 21 the board voted 3-0 to approve written findings that the developer broke two sections of the town's storm water code: releasing sediment-laden water on six occasions, for a $1,500 fine, and failing to stabilize the site on 53 occasions, 50 of them in dry weather, for a $5,750 fine, for a total of $7,250.
The findings also set out the repairs the developer must finish before a stop work order on the site is lifted, and the board left the order in effect. When staff reviewed that list Sept. 21, seven of the eight items were unresolved, among them a larger skimmer at Pond 2, seeding in Phase 3, a temporary berm behind Phase 2 back yards and the engineered fix for Phases 5 and 6 that was approved Aug. 10, and only the beaver traps were done.
The new count
At the Oct. 19 meeting, Chief Deputy Engineer Matt Gavelek reported that the stabilization violation had continued for 63 more days and that sediment-laden water had left the site twice more during rain. Gavelek said the town code sets $250 for each second and later violation, which adds $15,750 and $500. Gavelek and storm water Superintendent Mark O'Dell said they would prepare a notice of violation and fines in those amounts with the town's associate attorney.
If the board imposes them, the developer's fines would total $23,500, by PC360's math.
Both sides
At the August hearing, Eric Gastovich, a principal of Olson Farm LLC, told the board the company had spent close to $500,000 on required erosion control at the development. He said Kemper Ditch, the regulated drain the property empties into, had lost all its capacity in the weeks before the hearing and backed water up five feet or more, and that he believed state drainage law required the town to present the county a maintenance plan for that outlet.
At the September meeting, responding to residents' comments from the August hearing, staff said the town has no record of a request from the developer about the drain before late July, when a beaver dam was found, and noted that the hearing findings say the town is not responsible for maintaining the regulated drain. Gavelek said the beaver dam contributed to flooding of nearby properties, along with water from off the site overloading Pond 1 and a lack of homeowners association upkeep, but that photos showed it did not contribute to the December 2025 and June 2026 flooding on Tanglewood Lane or in Phase 2 back yards.
At the October meeting, James Fetzer of Redwood Lane, speaking for the Easton Park Neighborhood Coalition, told the board the developer has sued the town. He said homeowners face a Jan. 31, 2027, turnover under their covenants that would shift storm water and infrastructure responsibility from the developer to them, and he asked the town not to accept the subdivision's storm water system until an independent engineer confirms it has been fixed. Wittig said the board heard the comments but could not respond because of ongoing litigation. The board and the Town Council met in a joint executive session Oct. 8 to discuss pending or threatened litigation.
The town offices at 1490 Broadway can be reached at 219-926-1641.
Label: Reported by us.
Corrections
No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.
Sources (6)
- Agenda, Chesterton Storm Water Management Board, Nov. 16, 2026, Town of Chesterton
- Minutes, Chesterton Storm Water Management Board, Oct. 19, 2026
- Minutes, Chesterton Storm Water Management Board, Sept. 21, 2026
- Minutes, Chesterton Storm Water Management Board, Aug. 17, 2026
- Minutes, joint executive session, Chesterton Storm Water Management Board and Town Council, Oct. 8, 2026
- Video, Stormwater Board Meeting 10-19-26, Town of Chesterton