Portage council votes 6-0 to keep public comment as it is; mayor says city is trying to put together money for storm-damaged sidewalks
The council also put off the 2027 salary ordinance until December, and the clerk-treasurer reported that Porter County's clerk-treasurers back a 0.75% countywide income tax.
PORTAGE, Ind. Updated 6:50 p.m. Nov. 14, 2026.
Correction, 9:50 a.m. Nov. 14, 2026: An earlier version of this story and its headline said Mayor Austin Bonta told residents that owners must fix sidewalks damaged in the Aug. 11 derecho. Bonta said sidewalks are legally the property owner's responsibility, and he also said the city can repair them under its ordinance, has documented every spot with storm-related sidewalk damage and is trying to put together money to decide how to handle them. This version also says plainly that the 6-0 vote leaves public comment unchanged.
The Portage City Council voted 6-0 on Tuesday, Nov. 10, with Councilwoman Penny Ambler absent, to deny a resolution that would have written rules for public comment at council, board and commission meetings, so public comment at City Hall keeps working the way it does now.
Mayor Austin Bonta, who runs the meetings and does not vote, told the council he had no strong opinion either way. "If you guys want to make rules on public comment, I will follow them," he said, adding that he would keep things as they are if the council liked them that way. When the motion to deny was seconded, Bonta described it as a motion "to just keep me in charge" of how public comment runs.
The same night, residents pressed the city about sidewalks broken in the Aug. 11 derecho. Bonta said sidewalks are legally the property owner's responsibility, but that the city can still repair them under its ordinance and is trying to put together money to decide how to handle them. In a Facebook comment on Saturday, he wrote that the city can use its sidewalk fund to fix storm-damaged sidewalks that a homeowner's insurance is not covering.
Public comment stays as it is
Resolution 26-13 had gone back and forth through the council's ordinance committee since the spring. The city attorney said the version on the table was the one presented about four months earlier. A council member said amendments had grown it into a document of about 10 pages before it was sent back, and that its aim was only to put the council's standard practice in writing.
Councilman Collin Czilli moved to adopt it so the council could discuss it, then withdrew that motion, and the council took up a motion to deny instead. Another council member, pointing to the residents who had just spoken at length, said that if speakers had been told to sit down after two minutes, "we wouldn't have heard the entire story," and asked to "just let it be the way it was."
Before the roll call, the member who had described the 10-page draft said the proposal had good intentions but that "there's no good solution here," with a choice between strict rules applied to everyone equally or the current practice of allowing public comment and moving business along when it turns repetitive.
On the roll call, Ferdinand Alvarez, Melissa Weidenbach, Gina Giese-Hurst, Bob Parnell, Victoria Vasquez and Czilli all voted yes to deny it.
Storm-damaged sidewalks
One resident asked whether any public money will help repair a sidewalk he said the storm damaged. Another asked whether orange barricades are enough to keep people off a sidewalk she said the storm lifted and broke, with winter coming.
Bonta said a sidewalk is the responsibility of the owner of the property it crosses, even though it sits on an easement the public may walk on. "We've received no money from the federal government or the state government when it comes to storm relief," he said.
What the city spends on storm cleanup, such as tree limb pickup, can be paid back afterward if the city follows the rules, Bonta said: FEMA covers 75%, and the state has said it will repay 75% of the remaining 25%. By PC360's math, that leaves the city paying 6.25% of those costs. Because sidewalks are the owner's responsibility, he said, any sidewalk repairs the city makes would not be reimbursed by the state or federal government at all.
Bonta said the city can still do that work: because a sidewalk sits on an easement, the city can repair it, and its ordinance has mechanisms that allow it. He said the city spent the last month documenting every spot with storm-related sidewalk damage and is trying to put together money to figure out how best to handle sidewalks across the city. He said he knows of at least one homeowner whose insurer paid for the repair after the city provided proof that its ordinance makes sidewalks the owner's job, and the city attorney offered the resident the same kind of letter.
In a comment on Saturday on PC360's Facebook post of the earlier version of this story in a Portage community group, Bonta wrote that the story had left out the fund. "We do have the ability to still fix them for areas where the storm caused damage and the homeowner's insurance is not covering it with our sidewalk fund, and that's the reason why we documented each one," he wrote, adding that the lack of reimbursement does not mean the city won't end up fixing sidewalks the storm damaged, only that it won't be repaid for that work. A State Board of Accounts audit of the city covering 2022 and 2023 lists a Sidewalk and Curb Waiver Fund that held $90,247 at the end of 2023; the mayor's comment did not say whether that is the fund he meant, what it may pay for or how much it holds now. Owners whose insurer will not pay for storm damage to a sidewalk can call City Hall at 219-762-5425, and the city attorney's ordinance letter for insurers is available on request.
Randy Reeder, the city's superintendent of streets and sanitation, said owners are responsible for marking off damaged sidewalks with stakes or yellow caution tape, and officials said residents may put up orange plastic fencing themselves.
A countywide income tax recommendation
Clerk-Treasurer Elizabeth Modesto reported that the clerk-treasurers of Porter County's cities and towns, meeting with a County Council representative under the state's new tax law, signed a 20-page recommendation to state legislators for a countywide local income tax of 0.75%, up from 0.5% now.
She said that for a taxpayer earning $97,000, the 0.75% rate comes to $727 a year. By PC360's math, the 0.25 percentage point increase is about $243 of that. Modesto said the recommendation is not binding, that the County Council would vote on it in 2028 if lawmakers do not change the law, and that the money would arrive in 2030, doubling the city's income tax collection.
She said the clerk-treasurers wanted the county to act together rather than have each city and town set its own rate and compete for residents, and that Portage could still adopt its own rate later if it needs more than 0.75%.
Other business
- The council tabled the second reading of Ordinance 26-23, which sets 2027 salaries for the city's appointed employees and officers, until its December meeting, after Bonta asked the council to hold it so a couple of confusing things in the draft could be straightened out.
- The council adopted Resolution 26-20, which Modesto described as the standard year-end transfers among budget line items.
- Three ordinances were introduced: 26-24 on fund line item titles, 26-25 an additional appropriation, and 26-26 dissolving dormant funds and moving what is left in them to the general fund, with no amounts read aloud.
- The ordinance committee is drafting a safety ordinance on portable generators, a member reporting for the committee said. Another official added that it would not limit residents' ability to use them, only where they run, such as not under windows or doorways or inside homes and garages.
- Other speakers raised the city's Flock license plate cameras, winter emergency shelter supplies and health concerns in one neighborhood. City officials asked two of them for their records and data and offered to follow up.
How to weigh in
The council meets at 6:30 p.m. on the first Tuesday of each month in the council chambers at City Hall, 6070 Central Ave.; the next regular meeting is Tuesday, Dec. 1. Meetings stream on the city's YouTube channel. The ordinance committee meets at 5:30 p.m. before each council meeting and invited the public to attend. City Hall's number is 219-762-5425.
Label: Reported by us.
Corrections
Correction, 9:50 a.m. Nov. 14, 2026: An earlier version of this story and its headline said Mayor Austin Bonta told residents that owners must fix sidewalks damaged in the Aug. 11 derecho. Bonta said sidewalks are legally the property owner's responsibility, and he also said the city can repair them under its ordinance, has documented every spot with storm-related sidewalk damage and is trying to put together money to decide how to handle them. This version also says plainly that the 6-0 vote leaves public comment unchanged.
If something else here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.
Sources (7)
- Portage City Council meeting video, Nov. 10, 2026, City of Portage
- City Council page, members and meeting schedule, City of Portage
- Office of the Mayor and Office of the Clerk-Treasurer pages, City of PortageAlso portagein.gov/224/Office-of-the-Clerk-Treasurer
- Streets and Sanitation page, City of Portage
- Porter County Derecho Cleanup Update, Porter County Recycling and Waste Reduction District
- Comment by Mayor Austin Bonta on PC360's post of this story, What's Up Portage Indiana! Facebook group, Nov. 14, 2026; a comment in a Facebook group that Facebook shows only to signed-in users, so it has no public web copy to link; Porter County 360 keeps a saved copy
- Financial Statement Audit Report of the City of Portage, Jan. 1, 2022, to Dec. 31, 2023, Indiana State Board of Accounts