Porter County commissioners deny NIPSCO's revised heavy-haul route and give first approval to higher development fees
The board voted down a longer route for NIPSCO's oversize transformer loads over county roads, including Hayes Leonard Road, and passed on first reading an ordinance its development director said would generally raise the department's fees about 40%.
PORTER COUNTY, Ind. Updated 11:40 a.m. CT Nov. 19, 2026.
The Porter County Board of Commissioners on Tuesday, Nov. 17, denied a revised road agreement and bond that would have sent NIPSCO's oversize "superload" deliveries onto 7.43 miles of county roads in Washington, Center and Union townships, after commissioners raised concerns about damage to roads the county cannot afford to repair.
The board also approved on first reading an ordinance raising the fees charged by the county's Department of Development and Storm Water Management, which would be the first change to those fees since 2019. No one spoke for or against the ordinance at its public hearing.
The votes were taken by voice at the Administration Center in Valparaiso, and no commissioner was heard voting no on either one. The board is Jim Biggs of the North District, Barb Regnitz of the Center District and Edward K. Morales of the South District.
A longer route for NIPSCO's loads
Commissioners heard Tuesday that they had approved the first road agreement for NIPSCO's Hobart Station superload permit at their Oct. 27 meeting. That route ran from Montdale Park Drive along County Road 325 East to Division Road, then Smoke Road to U.S. 30, Joliet Road and the Lake County line.
County development staff told the board the Indiana Department of Transportation had approved that route and then withdrew permission to travel a section of U.S. 30. A representative of G&L Corp., the hauler, told the board the state canceled its permits for a bridge crossing after a change in how its trailer's axle weights are rated, and that it now holds five approved state permits for a route that avoids that bridge.
The revised agreement would have taken the loads from Division Road along County Road 200 West to State Road 2, then County Road 150 West, also called Hayes Leonard Road, to U.S. 30 and Joliet Road. Staff said that comes to 7.43 miles of county road, up from 4.79 miles on the first route, and that the bond the company already obtained still met the county's reconstruction requirements.
A NIPSCO specialty projects manager told the board the loads are transformers. He said NIPSCO had looked at using a rail spur, which is owned by the railroad rather than NIPSCO, and confirmed that when NIPSCO asked the railroad about investing in the spur so it could take the equipment, the railroad said no. "We don't necessarily pick the route that we bring these transformers on," he said, adding that the company had done its due diligence with the municipalities along the way.
Commissioners pushed back. One said that when the board took up the first route last month, "I was told that every other option was exhausted." The same commissioner called Hayes Leonard Road "a roller coaster" and asked whether the power lines that cross it would have to be taken down, and was told they would not.
Morales asked what happens if damage shows up months after the hauling ends and the bond has been released. He pointed to the Babcock Bridge, which he said cost the county $1,082,000 after traffic was diverted onto it while the state closed State Road 149 for nearly a year. Staff told him the road agreement requires a maintenance bond for later inspections, and said that bond warrants the repair work rather than the whole road. Another commissioner said Morales and Regnitz had made "a good point" and echoed Regnitz in asking why NIPSCO did not invest in the rail spur so it could receive the equipment.
One commissioner suggested tabling the agreement so the board could meet with NIPSCO's leadership about rebuilding the route at the company's cost once the hauling was done. A company representative replied, "I can't speak to that."
Shortly before the vote, a commissioner said the county roads belong to its taxpayers and that "we're going to have to be ultra, ultra sensitive about what we're allowing on them, because we don't have the resources coming into the county government to repair something every time it breaks." The board then voted on a motion to deny the revised agreement and bond, and it carried.
NIPSCO said Thursday, Nov. 19, that it is aware of the commissioners' decision and is evaluating it. "We appreciate the Commissioners' review and consideration of the proposed route," Jessica Cantarelli, communications manager for Northern Indiana Public Service Co., said in an email to Porter County 360. "NIPSCO is currently evaluating the decision and will work with the appropriate local, county and state agencies to assess the next steps."
As it reviews its options, Cantarelli said, the company will keep coordinating with stakeholders on transportation routes, timing and other project logistics. "Safety remains our top priority, and any future transportation plans will be developed with careful consideration for public safety," she said. The statement did not name another route or say when the transformers would move.
Development fees
Executive Director Michael Jabo told commissioners the fees, which he tied to the office's work on reviews and permits, were last set in 2019 and that by his reading of the Consumer Price Index, prices have risen 30% since then. He said a projection to 2031, which he called the department's next opportunity to raise its fees, pointed to an increase of nearly 50%, so he settled in between and, by and large, aimed for 40%. He singled out the $1,200 fee for a planned unit development as "an incredibly low figure."
Jabo said the department pays all its employees' salaries and fringe benefits from the fees it collects, and that he hopes the added money will let it hire more help for building inspection and code enforcement.
Under House Enrolled Act 1001, this year's state housing law, starting in 2027 a county can raise its fees for building and development approvals only once every five years and by no more than the change in the Consumer Price Index over the five years before, unless its costs change substantially and it holds a public hearing. The board was told the law also lengthened the wait before a fee increase takes effect to 180 days, so the new fees would not apply until about June 2027.
Also on Tuesday
- The board approved on first reading the vacation of a small piece of public right of way next to 104 E. County Road 700 North, after it was made clear at the hearing that the vacation covers only a small triangle and none of the old railroad right of way the county still holds.
- County development staff said the state's contractor has handled 3,828 leaning trees and hanging limbs over county right of way and collected nearly 27,800 cubic yards of disaster debris, which is stockpiled at the county fairgrounds to be ground up and disposed of. South Haven and the area just east of Chesterton came first, the work is expected to take about six more weeks, and crews will make a second round.
- Commissioners were reminded of the Plan Commission's public hearing at 5:30 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, in the same chambers, a listening session required by House Enrolled Act 1001 on the county's zoning and development rules and housing. Staff said no amendments will be passed or recommended that night. PC360's preview has the details.
What's next
The commissioners next meet Tuesday, Dec. 8. Residents can reach the board's office in Suite 205 of the Administration Center, 155 Indiana Ave., at 219-465-3440, and meetings stream live through "Watch Live and Recorded Meeting Streams" at portercountyin.gov.
Label: Reported by us.
Corrections
No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.
Sources (5)
- Porter County Board of Commissioners meeting, Nov. 17, 2026, Porter County Government on YouTube
- Board of Commissioners agenda, Nov. 17, 2026, Porter County
- Board of Commissioners agenda, Oct. 27, 2026, Porter County
- House Enrolled Act 1001, 2026 session, Indiana General Assembly (IC 36-7-2.3-3, fee limits)
- Statement on the commissioners' route decision, NIPSCO Communications Manager Jessica Cantarelli, email to Porter County 360, Nov. 19, 2026 (no web copy)