Valparaiso's Damon Run sewer customers pay nearly twice the in-city rate; what water and sewer cost, town by town
Part one of PC360's look at household water and sewer bills compares a home using 4,000 gallons a month in Valparaiso, Chesterton, Burns Harbor and South Haven, from each utility's posted rates and the state's 2026 bill tables.
PORTER COUNTY, Ind. Updated 6:05 p.m. Nov. 14, 2026.
A home in Valparaiso's Damon Run sewer area that uses 5,000 gallons of water a month pays $117.22 for sewer service this year under the city's own code, while a home using the same amount on the city's regular inside-city rates now pays $59.99, by PC360's math from the city's posted rates. That is $57.23 more a month, nearly twice as much.
The city code makes the comparison itself: Section 51.39, which sets the rates for what it calls the Damon Run service area, says a customer there using 5,000 gallons pays $117.22 in 2026, against $55.58 for an inside-city customer in January 2026, and puts the difference at 111%. The city's next in-city sewer step took effect July 1, which narrowed the gap.
The code says the Damon Run rates "will not be imposed based on whether the customer in question is inside or outside the city limits, but rather will be based on whether the customer will be served by the distinct and separate Damon Run facilities." A map of the area is attached to Ordinance 27-2024, the code says. New connections there pay a one-time capacity fee of $4,909 for each equivalent dwelling unit.
The city's utility took over the Damon Run sewer system in 2019, and its wastewater is sent to Portage for treatment, Lakeshore Public Media reported in November 2024, when the council took up the increase. The city's rate adviser, Eric Walsh of Baker Tilly, told the council then that the higher Damon Run rates pass along Portage's rising treatment charges so that city customers do not subsidize the area. "Keep it fair for everyone. Payers pay their fair share of the cost," Walsh said, according to that report. The city says Damon Run sewer customers were not part of the in-city increase the council approved in April 2024.
The next steps are already written into the rates, with the Damon Run charge at 5,000 gallons rising to $124.26 on Jan. 1, 2027, the code says, and the in-city sewer charge rising to $64.72 on July 1, 2027, by PC360's math.
What a 4,000-gallon household pays
To compare towns, PC360 priced one household using 4,000 gallons a month on the smallest residential meter, 5/8-inch. That is the amount the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission uses in its yearly bill tables. The figures below are monthly charges before taxes, trash, deposits and late fees, and the totals are PC360's math from each utility's posted rates and the commission's 2026 bill tables.
| Where | Water | Sewer | Water and sewer | Storm water fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Valparaiso, inside the city | $37.08 | $52.68 | $89.76 | $12.50 |
| Valparaiso, outside the city limits | $42.60 | $60.55 | $103.15 | Not included |
| Chesterton | $58.99 | $55.50 | $114.49 | $6.83 |
| Burns Harbor | $58.99 | $40.75 | $99.74 | Not included |
| South Haven | $58.99 | $71.13 | $130.12 | Not included |
With its $12.50 storm water fee, an in-city Valparaiso home comes to $102.26 a month, and a Chesterton home with its $6.83 storm water fee comes to $121.32.
At 5,000 gallons, the sewer charge alone is $59.99 inside Valparaiso, $68.96 outside the city limits, $117.22 in the Damon Run area, $61.49 in Chesterton and $40.75 in Burns Harbor, where the rate is flat.
The $58.99 water figure for Chesterton, Burns Harbor and South Haven is Indiana American Water's average bill for 4,000 gallons as of Jan. 1, 2026, from the commission's 2026 table, which lists Burns Harbor, Chesterton, Portage, Porter and South Haven among the towns in the company's Northwest Indiana Operations. In March the commission approved a monthly charge of $2.39 per 5/8-inch meter for Indiana American customers, covering improvement projects completed and placed in service through Nov. 30, 2025. The company must file the charge with its rate schedule, for approval by the commission's water and wastewater division, before placing it into effect, the order says. The commission's table places those towns in the company's Area One, and Indiana American customers who use less water than the table's household pay less than that average, because the commission's February 2024 rate order gives every customer in Area One and Area Two the first 1,500 gallons a month with no charge beyond the monthly meter service charge.
Valparaiso
The City Council approved the current water and sewer increases 7-0 on April 22, 2024, the city says, in Ordinance 8-2024 for water and a sewer ordinance signed the same day, and both step up each July 1 through 2028. The water rates now in effect, Phase III, began July 1, 2026: a monthly service charge of $15.90, which includes $4.85 for public fire protection, plus $3.96 for each 100 cubic feet of water, the rate for the first 2,000 cubic feet used in a month. Sewer is a $23.43 monthly base charge plus $5.47 for each 100 cubic feet.
Summer sewer bills in the city can run lower than the usage alone would suggest. Every residential customer who has received at least three bills before June gets a reduced sewer rate for water used in June, July and August, billed in July, August and September, with the sewer charge based on the household's average use over the six billing cycles from November through April, the utility says. Pool owners who fill a pool before that summer average covers them pay sewer charges on that water, so the utility tells them to make sure their route has been read first.
Customers outside the city limits pay more, and the water ordinance says its outside-city rates and charges are "approximately 14.9% higher" than inside the city, and the sewer ordinance sets a separate, higher outside-city schedule. The storm water fee for a single-family home inside the city has been $12.50 a month since Jan. 1, 2019, the city says, and the council last amended its storm water rates in 2017.
The next water step, on July 1, 2027, raises the in-city service charge to $17.09 and the first-tier rate to $4.26 for each 100 cubic feet. By PC360's math, the 4,000-gallon household would then pay $39.87 for water and $56.83 for sewer.
Not every Valparaiso-area home is on the city's sewer, either: the city says Beauty Creek and Windsor Park customers buy city water but get sewer service from Aqua Indiana, and Aberdeen, Eagle Ridge and Autumn Oaks customers buy city water but get sewer service from the Nature Works Conservancy District.
The city is also preparing Bond Ordinance 12-2026, for three new wells feeding the Flint Lake Water Treatment Plant, at up to $10 million in bonds plus up to $4 million in cash. "No water rate increase will be required to fund these improvements," the utility says.
Chesterton
Chesterton's Town Council adopted its current sewer rates in Ordinance 2025-27 on Nov. 24, 2025, and they took effect Jan. 1, 2026. Sewer bills come every two months: a base charge of $63.08 on the smallest meters plus $5.99 for every 1,000 gallons. For a home using 4,000 gallons a month, that is $111.00 a bill, or $55.50 a month. An unmetered single-family home in town pays $122.98 every two months.
Some homes pay an added charge, as unmetered homes in what the ordinance calls the special utility area pay $104.41 a month, a $61.49 user charge plus a $42.92 debt service and reserve charge. The ordinance says that rate stays in effect until the next biennial rate study, and for metered homes in the area it says the debt charge "will be removed when the debt serving as the basis of this charge is fully discharged."
The town's treatment plant serves Chesterton, the Town of Porter and the Indian Boundary Conservancy District, the town says. Chesterton homes buy their water from Indiana American Water, and the town contracts with the company to shut off water service when a sewer bill goes unpaid. Past-due notices go out 10 days before a shutoff, and once an account is 90 days past due the town can also place a tax lien on the property, its rates page says. The residential storm water fee is $6.83 a month, a $4.65 base rate plus $2.18 for one equivalent residential unit, which the town sets at 3,585 square feet of hard surface.
Burns Harbor
Burns Harbor charges a flat sewer fee of $40.75 a month for each equivalent residential unit, and a home counts as one unit, so the charge is the same whatever the household uses, the town says. The town owns its treatment plant, which sits at Cleveland-Cliffs on U.S. 12 and is operated by the company, while water comes from Indiana American Water. On Wednesday the Town Council adopted an ordinance defining which part of a sewer line belongs to the homeowner, as PC360 reported.
South Haven
South Haven homes on Aqua Indiana's South Haven Division sewer paid an average of $71.13 a month for 4,000 gallons as of Jan. 1, 2026, the commission's 2026 wastewater table shows, from a rate order dated May 28, 2019. With Indiana American's $58.99 for water, that comes to $130.12 a month.
Who sets the rates
Indiana American Water and Aqua Indiana are investor-owned, and the commission sets their rates in formal cases, while the city and town utilities priced here set their own by ordinance. A 2020 ordinance posted by Ogden Dunes, whose town-owned waterworks serves about 640 customers, says it had been reported that about 93% of Indiana's municipally owned water utilities had left the commission's oversight of their rates, as state law allows. Valparaiso, Hebron, Kouts and Ogden Dunes all run their own water utilities, and none of the four appears in the commission's 2026 water table.
Portage's council adopted Ordinance 24-19, restating the rates and charges of the city's storm water and sanitation utilities and amending those of its wastewater utility, by a 6-1 vote on Aug. 13, 2024, with a first $4 increase effective Oct. 1, 2024, its minutes show. Part two of this series will add Portage, Porter, Hebron, Kouts, Ogden Dunes, Beverly Shores, Dune Acres and Pines, with each town's current schedule priced the same way.
What we asked
PC360 asked Valparaiso City Services on Saturday how many homes and businesses pay the Damon Run rates, how much of the difference comes from the treatment charges Portage bills the city, whether any plan would bring the two rates closer, and who supplies water in the area. This story will be updated with the city's answer.
Questions and help
Customers of Indiana American Water or Aqua Indiana with questions about a rate case can reach the Indiana Office of Utility Consumer Counselor at 1-888-441-2494 or uccinfo@oucc.in.gov, and billing or service complaints go to the commission at 1-800-851-4268. Indiana American customers who cannot pay by the due date can call the company before that date at 1-800-492-8373 to set up a plan to pay the balance over time, and eligible homes can sign up for free budget billing, which evens out payments across the year, the company says. Chesterton's utility billing office is at 219-926-1572, and Burns Harbor's utility clerk is at 219-787-1165.
See also
Label: Reported by us.
Corrections
No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.
Sources (17)
- Valparaiso Code of Ordinances, Section 51.39, Rates and Charges for the Damon Run Service Area, American Legal Publishing
- Rates and Deposits; Metered Rates and Charges; Monthly Service Charge; Monthly Minimum Charge; Sewer Rates; Stormwater Rates; 2026 Bond Project, Valparaiso City Services
- Summer Sprinkling Rate Reduction, Valparaiso City Services, read Nov. 14, 2026
- City of Valparaiso Ordinance 8-2024, water rates and charges, with Exhibit AAlso valparaisoutilities.org/DocumentCenter/View/1496
- "Valpo considering sewer rate hike for Damon Run area to pass along increasing costs from Portage," Lakeshore Public Media, Nov. 18, 2024
- Town of Chesterton Ordinance 2025-27, sewage works rates and chargesAlso chestertonin.org/133/Rates-Fees
- Sanitation and Trash Department, Town of Burns Harbor
- Water, Town of Porter
- 2026 Annual Water Bill Analysis and 2026 Annual Wastewater Bill Analysis, as of Jan. 1, 2026, Indiana Utility Regulatory CommissionAlso secure.in.gov/iurc/files/2026-Wastewater-Billing-Survey.pdf
- Order in Cause No. 42351 DSIC 15, Indiana-American Water Company, March 18, 2026, Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission
- Order in Cause No. 45870, Indiana-American Water Company rate case, Feb. 14, 2024, Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission
- Customer Assistance Programs, Indiana American Water, read Nov. 14, 2026
- Town of Ogden Dunes Ordinance 867, removing the waterworks from IURC jurisdiction
- Water Department, Town of Hebron
- Town of Kouts, posted 2025 water rate ordinance
- Contact Us, Indiana Office of Utility Consumer Counselor
- City of Portage Common Council, special meeting minutes, Aug. 13, 2024