Indiana Supreme Court accepts Porter County Judge Christopher Buckley's resignation and permanent ban from the bench
Buckley admitted both misconduct counts tied to his August OWI arrest in Michigan City, including invoking his office to seek leniency, under an agreement with the state's judicial ethics commission. His resignation takes effect Friday, nearly six weeks before his term was set to end.
PORTER COUNTY, Ind. The Indiana Supreme Court on Friday accepted an agreement under which Porter Superior Court 4 Judge Christopher A. Buckley resigns from the bench effective Nov. 20 and is permanently barred from judicial office in Indiana, in the misconduct case the state's Commission on Judicial Qualifications brought over his August arrest for operating a vehicle while intoxicated.
In the agreement, which Buckley and four commission attorneys signed Wednesday and tendered to the court Thursday, Buckley admits both counts the commission filed in October. He admits that by driving while intoxicated he failed to comply with the law and undermined public confidence in the judiciary, and that by invoking his judicial office to obtain leniency during the police investigation he abused the prestige of the office to advance his personal interests. "Respondent accepts responsibility for the conduct stipulated above and admits the violations charged in both counts," the agreement says.
Chief Justice Loretta H. Rush signed the order, which says all justices concur. The court accepted the agreement's facts and sanctions and wrote that "continued litigation of this matter, including the appointment of Masters, would be an inefficient use of limited judicial resources." Under Indiana law, Buckley must submit his resignation to the governor, the order says. The court said an opinion explaining the decision will follow.
The ban covers holding judicial office or performing any judicial function in Indiana "whether by election, appointment, assignment, or otherwise," including service as a judge pro tempore, senior judge, magistrate, commissioner, master or referee, according to the agreement.
Buckley, a Republican, lost the Nov. 3 election for the Superior Court 4 seat to Democrat Heather A. McCarthy, 33,838 votes to 24,649, according to Porter County's unofficial results, last updated Nov. 16. The order notes his term was scheduled to end Dec. 31. He has been on a paid, voluntary leave of absence from the bench since Aug. 19, the agreement says, and the Supreme Court appointed Senior Judge Michael N. Pagano on Oct. 14 to hear cases in Porter Superior Court, the court system said in October.
What the agreed facts say
According to the stipulated facts, a Michigan City police captain working off-duty security at a concert on Aug. 15, at about 9:05 p.m., saw Buckley drive and park in an area closed to the public. When the captain asked whether he could help, Buckley replied, "Can't you read?" and gestured toward a large decal on the vehicle that read "KEEP BUCKLEY JUDGE," the agreement says.
Buckley could not perform the horizontal gaze nystagmus test as instructed or complete the walk-and-turn test, told officers he was a disabled veteran with balance difficulties, and declined a portable breath test, according to the agreement. When the captain again told him he was not free to leave, Buckley said, "I'm a Judge," and he refused a chemical breath test. When the captain called the on-call prosecutor for a search warrant, Buckley said, "I'm a Judge; you've just ruined my career," the agreement says. A blood test at Northwest Health-LaPorte Hospital showed an alcohol concentration of 0.221, and Buckley told officers that the judge who signed the warrant was his friend and that the Fraternal Order of Police had endorsed his campaign.
"Respondent acknowledges that, during the August 15, 2026 investigation, he invoked his judicial office and referred to his connections and the consequences for his career to obtain leniency from law enforcement," the agreement says.
Buckley pleaded guilty Aug. 17 in LaPorte Superior Court to operating a vehicle while intoxicated, a Class C misdemeanor, and was sentenced to 60 days in jail with 58 suspended, 180 days of probation and an alcohol evaluation and treatment as directed by probation. Two Class A misdemeanor counts, one of them operating a vehicle with an alcohol concentration of 0.15 or more, were dismissed under the plea agreement.
What Buckley's answer disputed
In his written response to the charges, docketed Nov. 9, Buckley, who filed it on his own behalf, admitted that he violated the three conduct rules named in the two counts and admitted most of the commission's factual allegations but denied several.
He denied the commission's statement that he was convicted of operating while intoxicated in 2009. The agreed facts now say he was charged with that offense in Hobart City Court in July 2009, while in law school and before he became a lawyer, and pleaded guilty that August to reckless driving, a Class A misdemeanor. He denied the commission's allegation that court staff said he arrived at work "reeking" of alcohol on May 6, and, saying he lacked personal knowledge of what the commission was told, he denied its statement that it confirmed he had a case of beer in his chambers. Neither allegation appears in the agreed facts the court accepted.
On saying "I'm a Judge" when, according to the commission's charges, the captain grabbed his arm, Buckley wrote that "the context of this comment was in reference to physical restraint not being necessary and that Respondent would comply." He also wrote that he has knee injuries related to his military service and receives disability compensation. On the officers' observations and the sobriety test results, he wrote that he lacked personal knowledge but had "no reason to dispute" them.
The record the court weighed
The agreed sanction factors say the August arrest was Buckley's second charge for operating while intoxicated but his first such conviction, that he presided over a criminal docket that included cases of the same kind, and that his conduct was prejudicial to the administration of justice. The commission publicly admonished him in 2021 for changing defendants' bonds as Lowell Town Court judge without a motion from the prosecution, notice to the defendants or a chance for them to be heard, and the August misconduct came while a March 2025 deferred resolution agreement with the commission was in effect, the agreement says. That agreement followed an August 2024 dispute, during which he had consumed alcohol, that was reported to Valparaiso police and that Buckley reported to the commission himself; a special prosecutor declined to file charges. The agreement required Buckley to continue therapy and enter a monitoring agreement with the Judges and Lawyers Assistance Program. The commission rescinded it after his arrest and conviction. The conditional agreement also notes he has no previous record of suspension as a judge or as a lawyer.
More from Porter County courts and government
- Porter County Judge Christopher Buckley files response to state misconduct charges over his August OWI arrest
- Porter County's Monday update lifts turnout to 44.8% with no leader changed; county site still marks totals unofficial
- Porter County task force backs raising the local income tax to 0.75%, about $125 more a year on $50,000 of taxable income
Label: Reported by us.
Corrections
No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.
Sources (7)
- Published Order Accepting Conditional Agreement and Respondent's Resignation from Judicial Office, with the Statement of Circumstances and Conditional Agreement for Discipline attached, In the Matter of Christopher A. Buckley, case 26S-JD-373, Indiana Supreme Court, Nov. 20, 2026, document on the MyCase docket, read Nov. 20, 2026
- Respondent's Response to Notice of the Institution of Formal Proceedings and Statement of Charges, case 26S-JD-373, docketed Nov. 9, 2026, document on the MyCase docket, read Nov. 20, 2026
- In the Matter of Christopher Allen Buckley, case 26S-JD-00373, Indiana Supreme Court, MyCase docket, read Nov. 20, 2026
- Notice of the Institution of Formal Proceedings and Statement of Charges, Indiana Commission on Judicial Qualifications, filed Oct. 16, 2026
- Press release, "Discipline charges filed against Porter County judge," Indiana Judicial Branch, Oct. 16, 2026
- 2026 General Election results, unofficial, Porter County, last updated Nov. 16, 2026, read Nov. 20, 2026
- Earlier PC360 story: Porter County Judge Christopher Buckley files response to state misconduct charges, Nov. 12, 2026