Reported by us | Valparaiso

Valparaiso council votes to raise building and planning fees in one step; a 1,500-square-foot home permit would go from $787 to $1,782 in 2027

The City Council voted 5-1 for the full new fee schedule with no phase-in, moving the money into a separate fund the new state housing law requires, and added a yearly review of the fees.

By Chuck Vieira and the PC360 Government Desk | Published Nov. 12, 2026 | Updated Nov. 18, 2026, 6:15 p.m. CT | Last verified Nov. 18, 2026, 6:26 p.m. CT

VALPARAISO, Ind. Updated 6:15 p.m. Nov. 18, 2026.

Building a house, adding on or rezoning land in Valparaiso will cost more next year, after the City Council voted 5-1 on Monday, Nov. 9, to adopt a new building and planning fee schedule in full rather than phasing it in.

Under the schedule the city presented, the building permit fee for a 1,500-square-foot house rises from $787 to $1,782, and for a 3,000-square-foot house from $1,309 to $2,964. The inspection fee for a single-family home goes from $100 to $228, a certificate of occupancy from $25 to $57, and the fee to rezone land from $150 to $1,000 plus $20 an acre.

The council passed Ordinance 26 on its second reading, amending Chapter 150.05 of the city code. On the roll call, council members Jack Pupillo, Ryan Moore, Ellen Kapitan, Emilie Hunt and Barbara Domer voted yes, and Robert Cotton voted no. Council Member Diana Reed did not vote on the fees; when she asked earlier in the meeting whether she could vote on the related fund ordinance, she was told she could, but that "the next vote, you will not be able to cast your vote."

Trista Hudson of Cender Dalton, who presented the fee study with City Administrator Steve Poulos, reminded the council that under the statute the new fees "go into effect six months after they're approved."

Under House Enrolled Act 1001, that clock starts when the ordinance is published. An ordinance that raises building permit fees on new development must be published once within 30 days after the council adopts it, and the increase can't start until 180 days after that publication. By Porter County 360's math, the higher permit fees on new homes can start no earlier than early May 2027, or later if the ordinance is published later in that window, and the current fees apply until then.

Why the fees changed

The change follows House Enrolled Act 1001, the 2026 state housing law. It requires cities to put any fee for construction, zoning, development, subdivision or rezoning approvals into a new fund that pays only for that work, starting Jan. 1, 2027, according to the city's presentation. Those fees no longer go to the general fund, and the money cannot revert to other funds.

Before the fee vote, the council voted 7-0 to create that fund, the Building and Construction Fund, under Ordinance 25. Members first corrected two state law citations that Hunt pointed out had been written for towns rather than cities.

The fees came before the council at four meetings this fall. Hudson presented the state law and a proposed schedule with two phase-in options on Sept. 28, the council discussed it again Oct. 12 without taking action, and it held the first reading and a public hearing Oct. 26 before the final vote Nov. 9, according to the minutes and the meeting recording. Poulos told the council Oct. 26 that the process had also included one-on-one meetings and a budget committee discussion, the minutes say.

The city is moving the cost of that work out of the general fund along with the fees, though Hudson told the council Oct. 26 that the statute does not require any expenses to move and that leaving them in the general fund would be inadvisable, the minutes say. In the Sept. 28 presentation, fee revenue of about $550,000 projected for 2026 was set against more than $1 million in related costs, a gap the minutes say was "historically subsidized by the General Fund," and by Oct. 12 the city's analysis put those costs at about $1.5 million. On Oct. 26, Clerk-Treasurer Holly Taylor said the four Building Department employees, about $601,000 without health insurance, would move over to the new fund, and when Hunt asked how moving the expenses would affect the general fund, Hudson explained that the revenues move with the expenses, so cash is reduced on both sides, according to the minutes.

At the first reading Oct. 26, Poulos told the council that planning fees had not been raised since before 2004, building fees since 2013 and engineering fees apparently since the late 1980s or early 1990s, according to the minutes. No one from the public spoke at that night's public hearing on the fees, but later in the meeting, during public comment, resident James Ferguson urged the council to weigh the consequences of not raising them, saying all residents now subsidize the cost of new development and permits and that he would rather the people pulling permits pay those costs, the minutes say.

The city's projections lay out the gap the fees are meant to close. Planning, zoning and building permit fees are expected to bring in $544,027 in 2026. Under the full schedule, the city projects the new fund taking in about $1.48 million a year starting in 2027, including $1,374,964 from those fees and about $100,000 from contractor registrations. On the other side of the ledger, 2027 costs come to about $1.52 million for the building and planning departments and the parts of engineering, utilities and fire that do this work, not counting health insurance, which leaves the fund about $38,000 short in 2027 with the full fees. The city's table counts the same full-fee revenue in 2027 as in every later year, even though Hudson said the new fees take effect six months after approval. A four-year phase-in would have left a 2027 gap of $661,170, and a three-year phase-in a gap of $594,727.

"All of this decision tonight is really about financial stability for the city," Hudson said. She said the higher fees go a long way toward bridging a gap of about $900,000 between roughly $600,000 in current revenue and the nearly $1.5 million the service costs, shifting most of that cost from the general fund, paid by all residents and businesses, to the people who use the services.

What it costs

For remodels and other construction, the permit fee rises from $5 to $11 per $1,000 of project cost for the first $10,000, and from $3 to $7 per $1,000 above that. The inspection fee stays at 10% of the permit, with the minimum going from $25 to $45 and the maximum from $175 to $450. For a $10,000 fence, Hudson said, the total goes from $75 to $155.

New subdivisions pay more at several steps, starting with a new review fee of $500 plus $25 a lot for single-family and two-family projects, where none existed before. A primary plat goes from $150 plus $10 a lot to $1,000 plus $25 a lot, and new erosion control fees apply: $20 an acre for a subdivision and $250 for each individual lot. A development standards variance for a single-family or two-family home goes from $50 to $300.

The city figures a new home's permit by multiplying its gross area by the International Code Council's construction cost per square foot and a permit fee multiplier, which its fee page lists as 0.0019 under the current schedule, so the fee depends on the size and type of the house rather than its sale price. In a comparison chart from the city's Sept. 28 council presentation, included again in its Nov. 9 presentation, the permit for the same 1,500-square-foot house cost $1,724 in Portage, $1,296 in Porter County, $2,437 in Crown Point, $1,621 in Fishers, $1,338 in Greensburg and $519 in Goshen, so Valparaiso's new $1,782 would rank second highest of the seven, below only Crown Point. Those were the other places' fees at the time, and Domer noted at the first reading that the comparison assumes they make no changes of their own. Asked that night where the city would rank under the proposed fees, Hudson said it would remain in the lower middle, not at the top, and that on four sample projects it would rank third on three and second on one, the minutes say.

Some fees stay where they are, and the larger ones a new home pays are not part of this change. The city's table keeps the Board of Zoning Appeals fee for an administrative appeal at $200 and for a limited use at $100, keeps the special meeting fees at $1,000 for the zoning board and $1,500 for the Plan Commission, and lists no proposed amount for a comprehensive plan amendment or a zoning text amendment, which now cost $250 each, or for a wireless communications approval, now $500. Park impact fees and water and sewer hookup fees, which are much larger, are not being increased, Hudson told the council Oct. 26, according to the minutes.

On the commercial side, the city's sample projects show total fees for a Culver's restaurant rising from $2,561 to $7,175, for the Meijer project from $26,564 to $62,056, and for the Pratt Industries project from $103,239 to $244,432.

The city issued 1,261 building permits in 2025 and 904 through Oct. 2 this year, and about three in four are residential.

The debate over attainable homes

How the higher fees would affect home buyers came up at each of those meetings. On Sept. 28, Moore noted that higher fees would ultimately be passed through to homebuyers, and on Oct. 12 Domer raised the same concern and Cotton asked about the state law's housing affordability goals, according to the minutes. On Oct. 26, Kapitan cited the attainability goals the council had discussed with developers, and Hudson said the increase for a 1,500-square-foot new home averages about $1,000, while the minutes record that the building director did not expect the increase to inhibit building.

On Nov. 9, Hudson showed the council five new-home sales in Valparaiso, priced from $285,900 to $1,228,859. On those homes the proposed building permit fee came to between 0.36% and 0.5% of the sale price, up from 0.17% to 0.22% under the current fees, an increase of less than a third of a percentage point in each case. Hudson said Building and Code Enforcement Director Vicki Thrasher was "very convinced," citing an email to the council earlier that day, "that these change in prices are not going to affect the home sales in Valparaiso," and later in the meeting she called the amounts on the screen "very low and negligible and still affordable."

Domer said the council worked this year to have developers include attainably priced homes in four new developments, and that three of the four are projected to build 135 of them in 2027. "I just can't reconcile that right now at least for 2027 especially because the city has a balanced budget and we don't need the money in 2027," she said, though she went on to vote for the ordinance.

Reed, who could not vote on the fees, spoke for the full increase. "To phase them in would mean that we are leaving money on the table that could have been used for other city related priorities," she said, adding that the fees are paid once and are being raised "not so that we can get ahead" but "because we're behind." She asked the council to consider, later, a committee that could set up a discount for qualifying buyers of homes under 1,300 square feet.

The motion added a new section requiring a yearly review of the fee schedule. As described before the vote, department heads would weigh costs, inflation and comparisons with other communities and bring any recommended change, up or down, to the council. Those reviews will run inside state limits: starting Jan. 1, 2027, the same housing law caps these fees at what is reasonably necessary to cover the city's cost, and any of them may rise only once every five years, by no more than inflation over that span. A bigger change is allowed only if the city's cost substantially changes, and only after the council holds a public hearing. During the discussion, council members were advised that if they do not want the added general fund money spent without their say, they could cut that amount from the 2027 budget in January and appropriate it again later through the additional appropriation process.

Other business

The council heard that Valparaiso Community Schools has about $2,500 left from its 2025 city opioid grant and wants to use it for what staff called opioid goggles, for a student program run through school social workers and school resource officers. An amendment to the grant agreement will come back to the council, and two council members asked that the district come in to present. Council members also congratulated Domer, who won the Nov. 3 race for clerk of the Circuit Court in unofficial results, and noted she will serve on the council until the first of the year.

What comes next

The City Council next meets at 6 p.m. Monday, Nov. 23, at City Hall, 166 Lincolnway. Meetings stream live on the city's website, comments on agenda items may be sent before a meeting to mpalmer@valpo.us, and the city can be reached at 219-462-1161.

Under state law, IC 36-4-6-14, an ordinance the council passes is considered adopted once the presiding officer signs it and the mayor approves it, or once the council passes it over the mayor's veto. Mayor Jon Costas told the council Oct. 26 that charging rates in line with actual expenses made sense and would not meaningfully affect investment in the community, though the decision belongs to the council, the minutes say.

Porter County 360 asked Marci Palmer, executive assistant to the mayor, on the afternoon of Thursday, Nov. 12, for the two ordinances as adopted with the fee schedule, the date the new fees take effect and why Reed did not vote on the fees, and asked Cotton the same afternoon why he voted no. On Sunday, Nov. 15, Porter County 360 emailed council members Pupillo, Moore, Kapitan, Hunt, Domer and Reed for their views on the vote, and this story will be updated with any answers.

Label: Reported by us.

Corrections

No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.

Sources (13)

  1. House Enrolled Act 1001, 2026 session, Indiana General Assembly (IC 36-4-6-14(a), adoption with the mayor's approval; IC 36-4-6-14(e), publication and 180-day wait; IC 36-7-2.3, fee limits)
  2. City Council meeting recording and caption track, Nov. 9, 2026, City of Valparaiso (BoxCast
  3. Building and Construction Fund and HEA 1001 fee presentation, City Council meeting Nov. 9, 2026, City of Valparaiso
  4. City Council meeting agenda, Nov. 9, 2026, City of Valparaiso
  5. City Council meeting agenda, Oct. 26, 2026, City of Valparaiso
  6. City Council meeting minutes, Sept. 28, 2026, City of Valparaiso
  7. City Council meeting minutes, Oct. 12, 2026, City of Valparaiso
  8. City Council meeting minutes, Oct. 26, 2026, City of Valparaiso
  9. Emails from Porter County 360 to Marci Palmer and Council Member Robert Cotton, Nov. 12, 2026, and to council members Pupillo, Moore, Kapitan, Hunt, Domer and Reed, Nov. 15, 2026 (no web copy)
  10. Building Department Fees and New Construction Fees pages, City of Valparaiso, read Nov. 15, 2026Also ci.valparaiso.in.us/83/New-Construction-Fees
  11. Unofficial general election results, Nov. 3, 2026, Porter County
  12. Staff Directory, City of Valparaiso, read Nov. 12, 2026
  13. Cender Dalton Municipal Advisors staff page, Trista Hudson, municipal advisor

This story on the full site