Built for Civil War soldiers in 1893, the Memorial Opera House gave Jimmy Stewart's film mother her first stage
A walk back through 133 years at 104 Indiana Ave., from brick-by-brick fundraising and vaudeville nights to the guild that saved it, as the opera house fills its holiday season again.
VALPARAISO, Ind. When the doors of the Memorial Opera House open for "The Secret Garden" on Friday, Nov. 27, the audience will walk under a brick arch that Porter County families helped pay for one brick at a time, in a hall raised in 1893 to honor the county's Civil War soldiers and sailors.
The building at 104 Indiana Ave. began as Memorial Hall, in memory of the county's soldiers and sailors who lost their lives in the war, and its dedication later grew to take in veterans of every war, the opera house says. The idea came from Valparaiso's Chaplain Brown Post of the Grand Army of the Republic, the Union veterans' group, which started a public subscription drive, and the county commissioners supplied the lot and more money, according to the building's 1984 nomination to the National Register of Historic Places. Residents bought bricks for the building fund, neighbors raised more with lectures, dinners and bake sales, and the Women's Relief Corps worked to see the project through, the opera house's own history recalls.
Architect Charles Lembke drew the plans, John D. Wilson and Sons built it, and the hall was finished in November 1893 for $9,950, the opera house says. Above the entrance, a panel reads "A monument to the Soldiers and Sailors of 1861-5," the nomination records.
A night out in the 1890s
Picture the street in those first years: a two-story red brick hall with a round tower at each front corner, a broad, low arch over the main doors and a stained glass fanlight above, details the nomination tied most closely to the Queen Anne style, with a nod to the Chicago architects of the day. Inside, the side boxes were framed by turned posts and topped with lattice, the 1984 nomination noted, "not unlike the treatment that would be seen on the front porch of a Queen Anne house."
The veterans held patriotic rallies, concerts and lectures there, and Theodore Roosevelt appeared at the hall "amid great fanfare" in 1900 while campaigning for vice president, the nomination says. Those events apparently did not pay the bills, though, and in 1901 the county took over the post's debts and the building. Albert F. Heineman then leased the hall and brought minstrel troupes, traveling theater companies, political figures and vaudeville to town.
The opera house counts John Philip Sousa, the Marx Brothers and Valparaiso University graduate Lowell Thomas among those who took its stage. Its history also remembers lighter fare: Bronte, billed as a "mathematical or mind-reading dog," and "Prof. Wm. M'Cormick, Whistling Imitator, Magician, Ventriloquist," whose Jan. 27, 1905, show was advertised in the Porter County Vidette.
A postcard from about 1907 caught the hall in its prime, with "music," "drama" and "vaudeville" among the words lettered across the canopy and posters for "Quo Vadis" propped along the sidewalk out front.
Valparaiso's own star
Beulah Bondi, who grew up in Valparaiso, was one child who stepped onto that stage and went on to Hollywood. She began acting at the Memorial Opera House as a young girl in "Little Lord Fauntleroy," then earned bachelor's and master's degrees at Valparaiso University, the opera house history says.
When the Academy Awards added a best supporting actress category, Bondi was among its first five nominees, for "The Gorgeous Hussy" at the ninth Academy Awards in 1937, the Academy's records show. Holiday viewers know her as Jimmy Stewart's mother in "It's a Wonderful Life," the opera house notes.
Bondi kept coming home to visit, and in 1967 she gave money that helped buy new seats for the hall where she started, the opera house says.
Saved by the guild
The performing arts thrived at the opera house until the 1920s, when movies took over, and through the 1920s, '30s and '40s it showed some films and local plays but sat empty much of the time, the nomination says. By the 1950s, demolition was on the table.
The Community Theatre Guild stepped in, leased the building from the county commissioners and went to work, with repairs and a stage for local talent; the nomination dates the guild's founding to 1957, while the opera house's own history says the hall was slated for demolition in 1955 when the guild stepped in. In 1967, about $250,000 went into a new floor, new seating and orchestra pit improvements, the nomination says. Today the guild makes its home at the Chicago Street Theatre, the opera house notes.
The hall was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1984, and its most recent renovation, finished in 2024, restored its architectural character while updating the building, the opera house says.
The season ahead
The old hall is busy again this winter, with "The Secret Garden" playing Nov. 27 through Dec. 13. Maestro Troy Webdell and the South Shore Orchestra return for the Holiday Pops at 2 and 7 p.m. Saturday, Dec. 19, and 2 p.m. Sunday, Dec. 20, when Santa leads the audience in a sing-along, the opera house said. Tickets for both are $30 for adults, $27 for seniors, students and military, and $60 for loge seats.
The hall has outlasted the Union veterans who first dreamed of it and come through the quiet decades after the movies took over, when it sat empty much of the time and there was talk of tearing it down.
Porter County built this hall in 1893 so it would remember its soldiers and sailors, and every time an audience walks in under that brick arch and the house lights dim, it still does.
See also
Label: Reported by us.
Corrections
No corrections to this story. If something here is wrong, tell us. Every correction is dated on the story and listed in our public log.
Sources (7)
- History, Memorial Opera House
- National Register of Historic Places Inventory, Nomination Form, Porter County Memorial Hall, prepared Feb. 1, 1984, National Park Service, NRIS 84001231
- The 9th Academy Awards, 1937, Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences
- Beulah Bondi, Wikipedia, read Nov. 12, 2026
- "Memorial Opera House, Valparaiso, Ind.," postcard about 1907, Steven R. Shook collection, Wikimedia Commons, license CC BY 2.0, unalteredAlso creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0
- The Secret Garden, Memorial Opera House calendar
- Holiday Pops, Memorial Opera House box office