A pale gray water tower with CHESTERTON painted across the tank, seen from below through the white blossoms of a flowering tree
A water tower in Chesterton, photographed in May 2013.Photo: hakkun, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Updated 6:05 p.m. Nov. 14, 2026.

For a household that buys its water from Indiana American Water in Portage, Chesterton, Porter, Burns Harbor or South Haven, a monthly bill for 4,000 gallons came to $58.99 at the start of 2026, more than twice the $23.08 the same amount cost in Michigan City, according to the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission's yearly water bill table.

The commission's 2026 Annual Water Bill Analysis lists average monthly bills as of Jan. 1, 2026. It places Indiana American's Northwest Indiana Operations, which it lists as Burns Harbor, Chesterton, Gary, Hobart, Merrillville, Portage, Porter and South Haven, in the company's "Area One," where towns from Kokomo to Jeffersonville share the same $58.99 figure.

By PC360's math, the gap with Michigan City comes to $35.91 a month, or about $431 a year, for a home that uses 4,000 gallons every month.

How the neighbors compare

These are the utilities near Porter County in the commission's table, by average monthly bill for 4,000 gallons:

  • Lowell, Indiana American Water's "Area Two": $70.65
  • Community Utilities of Indiana: $62.38
  • Indiana American Water, Area One, including the Porter County towns above: $58.99
  • Cedar Lake: $40.88
  • Aqua Indiana's Lake County Water Division: $39.76
  • East Chicago: $35.96
  • Schererville: $26.22
  • Michigan City: $23.08

The table notes that the figures for Indiana American, Aqua's Lake County division, Schererville and Michigan City include a fire protection surcharge for a 5/8-inch meter, and that a customer's location determines whether that surcharge applies. Valparaiso's water bills are not part of the table.

Who owns them, and when rates last changed

Indiana American Water, Aqua Indiana and Community Utilities of Indiana are investor-owned, the table shows, while Cedar Lake, East Chicago, Schererville and Michigan City are municipal. Indiana American's last rate order is dated Feb. 14, 2024, Michigan City's May 27, 2015, and Schererville's Dec. 14, 2005.

Indiana American's 2024 order closed a case in which the company asked to raise its yearly revenue by about 31.1%, or $86.7 million, according to the Indiana Office of Utility Consumer Counselor, the state agency that represents customers before the commission. The office recommended about 6.6%, or $18.6 million, and the commission approved an increase of about $66 million. The third step of those new rates took effect in May 2025, the commission said in a later order.

Under that 2024 order, the company also changed how it bills small users, so that every customer in Area One and Area Two gets the first 1,500 gallons a month with no charge beyond the monthly meter service charge, which the commission approved without opposition, finding that the design would help with affordability. The commission turned down the company's separate proposal for a discount rate for lower-income customers, which the order called the Universal Affordability Tariff.

A new charge approved in March

The Jan. 1 figures came before a new charge the commission approved for Indiana American customers. On March 18, the commission approved a distribution system improvement charge designed to bring in $12,219,511 a year, and its order says the company is "authorized to collect from each of its present and future water customers" a monthly charge of $2.39 for each equivalent 5/8-inch meter. Before "placing into effect" the charge, the order says, the company must file it with its schedule of rates for approval by the commission's water and wastewater division.

The charge covers what the order calls "non-revenue producing projects that were completed and placed in service" between the Step 2 rate base cutoff in the company's 2024 rate case and Nov. 30, 2025. The company's earlier charge of this kind had been reset to zero in May 2025, the order says.

By PC360's math, adding the $2.39 charge to the Jan. 1 figure gives about $61.38 a month for 4,000 gallons on a 5/8-inch meter, if nothing else on the bill changed.

State law lets investor-owned water and sewer utilities ask for such a surcharge as often as once a year to replace aging pipes between rate cases, the consumer counselor's office says, and the total cannot exceed 10% of the base revenue set in the utility's last rate case. Some costs, including replacing customer-owned lead service lines and work done because of road or highway construction, can be recovered through the charge without counting toward that cap.

Community Utilities customers

In February the commission approved Indiana American Water's purchase of Community Utilities of Indiana's utility properties in Lake, Porter, Jasper and Newton counties, the consumer counselor's office says. Community Utilities' $62.38 bill in the table comes from its own last rate order, dated May 3, 2021.

Questions and help

Indiana American customers who cannot pay a bill by its due date should call the company before that date at 1-800-492-8373, its customer assistance page says, and it will set up a plan to pay the balance over time. That plan may require paying at least 25% of the bill within 48 hours of the call and the rest, with any late charge, on a schedule of no more than 12 months, while keeping up with new bills. Customers who have broken a similar agreement in the past 12 months cannot get one, the page says. The company also offers free budget billing to eligible residential customers, which spreads payments evenly across the year. A household with a member whose emergency medical condition would be worsened by a shutoff may keep service for up to three months once a doctor or nurse practitioner completes the company's medical certificate.

Customers with questions about a pending utility case can reach the consumer counselor's office toll-free at 1-888-441-2494 or at uccinfo@oucc.in.gov. A billing, deposit or service complaint against a regulated utility goes to the commission, which can be reached toll-free at 1-800-851-4268.

See also

Label: Reported by us.